M. Cloete, Is Habermas a transcendental thinker? The question of the possibility of rationality as a philosophical theory, S AFR J PH, 19(2), 2000, pp. 95-117
Citations number
21
Categorie Soggetti
Philosiphy
Journal title
SOUTH AFRICAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY-SUID-AFRIKAANSE TYDSKRIF VIR WYSBEGEERTE
In this paper, I attempt to cast some light on the debate between and Rorty
on the question of the possibility of rationality as a philosophical theor
y. My assessment of this debate proceeds from the perspective of their resp
ective critiques of modern philosophy, defined as an epistemological discip
line within the Cartesian-Kantian tradition of foundationalism. While both
thinkers seem to be fairly clear on why they can no longer accept philosoph
ical theories of rationality which have their roots in the metaphysical tra
dition of modern philosophy, Rorty is convinced that Habermas, despite his
linguistic turn, does not quite succeed in breaking with the transcendental
problematic of the Kantian tradition. In what follows, I propose to invest
igate the accuracy of the charge of transcendentalism levelled by Rorty aga
inst Habermas.