Although a doctorate provides a library director with little practical assi
stance toward fulfilling his or her job, many college and university admini
strators seem to expect library directors to have one. The presence of the
doctorate has been studied extensively within ARL institutions, but not wit
hin small colleges. This article explores the presence of the doctorate amo
ng small college library directors, considering gender and tenure in additi
on to size of the library, the college, and the library staff. This researc
h finds that 20 percent of library directors at Baccalaureate I institution
s have doctorates, and 40 percent have second master's degrees. Librarians
with doctorates do not direct larger institutions than those without Ph.D.s
. The value of the doctorate, and its future among female directors in part
icular, is considered.