Background/Aims: The validity of mass screening using fecal occult blood te
sting remains controversial. In addition, no controlled clinical study has
yet been performed to show the usefulness of sigmoidoscopy. The purpose of
the present study was to compare the surgical results achieved in asymptoma
tic patients with colorectal cancer detected by screening with those in sym
ptomatic individuals.
Methodology: A total of 285 patients underwent a surgical resection of colo
rectal cancer between 1991 and 1997 at our institution. Among them, 233 pat
ients had complaints related to cancer at the time of diagnosis. In contras
t, 52 were asymptomatic. In those 52 patients, colorectal cancer had been s
uspected based on routine screening including fecal occult blood testing, c
olonoscopy and/or elevated serum levels of carcinoembryonic antigen,
Results: Early stage of colorectal cancer was more frequently seen in asymp
tomatic patients than in symptomatic patients P<0.01. The survival rates fo
r asymptomatic patients was also superior to those of symptomatic patients
P<0.05.
Conclusions: Screening using fecal occult blood testing, colonoscopy and tu
mor markers is thus considered to be beneficial for the early detection of
colorectal carcinoma, which also tends to demonstrate good surgical results
.