A model for coherent island formation in heteroepitaxial thin films is pres
ented by focusing on the interplay between surface and strain relaxation en
ergies. The resulting free energy is mapped onto the Landau free energy, an
d yields the local surface slope as the order parameter for island formatio
n. Isotropic islands are found to exhibit second-order transitions. We argu
e that our model is appropriate for describing the nucleation and stability
of island formation. The spinodal curve indicates that there exists an uns
table regime where spinodal-like islands emerge as low-slope islands, even
in a highly mismatched heteroepitaxial system. (C) 2000 American Institute
of Physics. [S0021- 8979(00)00521-1].