Background: Sucrose has been shown to have an analgesic effect in preterm a
nd term neonates. Sucrose, however, has a high osmolarity and may have dele
terious effects in infants with fructose intolerance. Furthermore, it may f
avour caries. We therefore investigated the effects of a commercially avail
able artificial sweetener (10 parts cyclamate and 1 part saccharin), glycin
e (sweet amino acid) or breast milk in reducing reaction to pain as compare
d with a placebo. Subjects: Eighty healthy term infants, four days old, wit
h normal birth weight. Interventions: The infants were randomly assigned to
one of four groups: 2 mi sweetener, glycine, expressed breast milk or wate
r were given 2 min before a heel prick for the Guthrie test. The procedure
was filmed with a video camera and analysed by two observers who did not kn
ow which medication the infant had received. Results: Using a multivariate
regression analysis, the following variables had significant correlation wi
th relative crying time and recovery time: behavioural state before the int
ervention, the pricking nurse, and die type of medication. Relative crying
time and recovery time were significantly less in the sweetener group but n
ot in the glycine and the breast milk group. Conclusions: The artificial sw
eetener used in our study reduces pain reaction to a heel prick in term neo
nates, and thus provides an alternative to sucrose. In contrast, glycine te
nds to increase pain reaction whereas breast milk has no effect. (C) 2000 E
lsevier Science Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.