It has been postulated that the adaptations of lower extremity function exh
ibited by anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficient and post-ACL surgical
patients represent early accommodations to the loss of ACL function after i
njury so that excessive anterior displacement of the tibia is prevented. Pr
ior studies have suggested that compensation patterns in ACL deficient and
post-ACL surgical subjects may affect joint moments of the knee as well as
the hip. However, the variance in knee and hip forces between ACL deficient
, post-surgical ACL and uninjured groups has not been clearly elucidated. T
he purpose of this study was to as sess hip:knee extensor torque ratios rel
ative to anterior tibia shear in pre-surgical-ACL deficient, post-surgical
and uninjured subjects. Measurements of hip and knee joint moments and ante
rior tibia shear were recorded from 45 injured and uninjured subjects (21 m
en, 24 women) during lower extremity, variable resistance exercise. Anterio
r tibia shear was computed by decomposing joint moments and reaction forces
according to a model derived from cadaver knee dissections and radiography
, in combination, to estimate the tibio-femoral compressive and shear force
s generated by the patellar tendon at various angles throughout the knee jo
int range. Three groups of subjects were studied: recently injured ACL defi
cient pre-surgical subjects who were scheduled for immediate surgery (PRE;
n = 15); postsurgical subjects who had undergone ACL reconstructive surgery
at least 1 year prior to testing (POST; n = 15); and uninjured controls (C
ON; n = 15). All PRE and POST subjects had a normal contralateral limb. Tes
ts were conducted under six conditions: 1 and 1.5 Hz cadence and maximal sp
eed at 33% and 50% one repetition maximum resistance. The results revealed
that the hip:knee ratios were significantly greater for the post-ACL surgic
al group than the PRE and CON groups (P < 0.01 P < 0.03). There were signif
icant negative correlations between the hip extensor:knee extensor torque r
atios and maximal anterior tibia shear. across all groups. The hip:knee ext
ensor torque ratio increased with decreased anterior tibia shear in all gro
ups with significant correlations ranging from -0.55 to -0.88 (P < 0.01) fo
r the injured limbs of PRE and POST groups, and -0.64 to -0.78; (P < 0.01)
for the CON group. The highest overall correlations were found for the post
-surgical subjects. The results revealed that anterior tibia shear declined
significantly with speed (P < 0.01) in all groups. However, the converse w
as true for the hip:knee extensor torque ratio across speeds. The ratio inc
reased significantly with speed(P < 0.001) for all groups at the 33% and 50
% resistances. The results suggest (1) that post-ACL surgical subjects appe
ar to accommodate to ACL substitution by using hip extensors to a significa
ntly greater extent than the uninjured controls in closed-chain lower extre
mity exercise; (2) that the hip:knee extensor torque ratio is significantly
related to the magnitude of anterior tibia shear; and (3) that the anterio
r tibia shear is significantly reduced as speed increases in closed-chain l
ower extremity exercise.