Va. Thompson et A. Paivio, MEMORY FOR PICTURES AND SOUNDS - INDEPENDENCE OF AUDITORY AND VISUAL CODES, Canadian journal of experimental psychology, 48(3), 1994, pp. 380-398
Three experiments examined the mnemonic independence of auditory and v
isual nonverbal stimuli in free recall. Stimulus lists consisted of (1
) pictures, (2) the corresponding environmental sounds, or (3) picture
-sound pairs. In Experiment 1, free recall was tested under three lear
ning conditions: standard intentional, intentional with a rehearsal-in
hibiting distracter task, or incidental with the distracter task. In a
ll three groups, recall was best for the picture-sound items. In addit
ion, recall for the picture-sound stimuli appeared to be additive rela
tive to pictures or sounds alone when the distracter task was used. Ex
periment 2 included two additional groups: In one, two copies of the s
ame picture were shown simultaneously; in the other, two different pic
tures of the same concept were shown. There was no difference in recal
l among any of the picture groups; in contrast, recall in the picture-
sound condition was greater than recall in either single-modality cond
ition. However, doubling the exposure time in a third experiment resul
ted in additively higher recall for repeated pictures with different e
xemplars than ones with identical exemplars. The results are discussed
in terms of dual coding theory and alternative conceptions of the mem
ory trace.