We have investigated mechanisms of dorsal-ventral patterning of neural
tissue, using Xenopus ectoderm neuralized by noggin protein. This tis
sue appears to be patterned dorsoventrally; cpl-1, a gene expressed in
the dorsal brain, and etr-l, a gene largely excluded from the dorsal
brain, are expressed in separate territories in noggin-treated explant
s (Knecht, A. K., Good, P. J., Dawid, I. B. and Harland, R. M. (1995)
Development 121, 1927-1936). Here we show further evidence that this p
attern represents a partial dorsal-ventral organization. Additionally,
we test two mechanisms that could account for this pattern: a dose-de
pendent response to a gradient of noggin protein within the explant, a
nd regulative cell-cell interactions. We show that noggin exhibits con
centration-dependent effects, inducing cpl-1 at low doses but repressi
ng it at high doses. Since noggin acts by antagonizing Bone Morphogene
tic Protein (BMP) signaling, this result suggests that BMPs also may a
ct in a dose-dependent manner in vivo. However, in the absence of a no
ggin gradient, regulative cell-cell interactions can also pattern the
tissue. Such regulation is facilitated by increased motility of noggin
-treated cells, Finally, the response of cells to both of these patter
ning mechanisms is ultimately controlled by a third process, the chang
ing competence of the responding tissue.