Runoff may be reduced by temporal water storage in depressions at the soil
surface. Depressional storage is difficult to measure and is usually estima
ted from some roughness index. The objective of this study was to compare t
he ability of selected roughness indices to describe maximum depressional s
torage (MDS). Height measurements were taken on 221 tilled soil surfaces ac
ross a range of roughnesses. Maximum depressional storage was determined fr
om digital elevation models (DEMs), The MDS values ranged from 0 to 13 mm.
Five roughness indices were calculated Dom transects across these DEMs: ran
dom roughness (RR), tortuosity (T), limiting elevation difference (LD) and
slope (LS), and mean upslope depression (MUD). Regression analysis of RIDS
on each of five roughness indices showed that RR best described depressiona
l storage (r(2) = 0.80). Prediction of RIDS in the field based on RR has an
uncertainty of +/- 3 mm (95% confidence interval). Variation was due to RR
and its nonspatial nature. To improve predictions of RIDS, the spatial con
figuration of the surface has to be taken into account.