Tm. Wynn et al., Effects of forest harvesting best management practices on surface water quality in the Virginia coastal plain, T ASAE, 43(4), 2000, pp. 927-936
Three small watersheds located in Westmoreland County, Virginia, were monit
ored to evaluate the impact of forest clearcutting on surface water quality
and to evaluate the effectiveness of forestry best management practices (B
MPs) for minimizing hydrologic and water quality impacts associated with ti
mber harvesting. One watershed (7.9 ha) was clearcut without implementation
of BMPs, one watershed (8.5 ha) was clearcut with the implementation of BM
Ps and a third watershed (9.8 ha) was left undisturbed as a control Forest
clearcutting without BMP implementation reduced storm runoff volume and did
not significantly change peak flow rates. Following site preparation, both
storm flow volumes and peak flow rates decreased significantly. For the wa
tershed with BMP implementation, storm flow volume decreased significantly
following harvest, while peakflow increased. Site preparation did not chang
e storm flow volumes over post-harvest conditions, bur did significantly re
duce storm peak flow rates. Disruptions in subsurface flow pathways during
harvest or rapid growth of understory vegetation following harvest could ha
ve caused these hydrologic changes. Harvest and site preparation activities
significantly increased the loss of sediment and nutrients during storm ev
ents, Storm event concentrations and loadings of sediment, nitrogen, and ph
osphorus increased significantly following forest clearcutting and site pre
paration of the No-BMP watershed. Both the BMP watershed and the Control wa
tershed showed few changes in pollutant storm concentrations or loadings th
roughout the study.
Results of this study indicate forest clearcutting and site preparation wit
hout BMPs can cause significant increases in sediment and nutrient concentr
ations and loadings in the Virginia Coastal Plain. However these impacts ca
n be greatly reduced by implementing a system of BMPs on the watershed duri
ng harvesting activities.