F. Schotz, 'Cultivated' and 'non-cultivated' folk music: On music-making among traditional dance musicians in Bavaria, WORLD MUSIC, 41(2), 1999, pp. 41-61
By orienting itself towards an academic-aesthetic sound ideal and thereby a
lmost fully ignoring the musics original functions, the Bavarian folk music
cultivation movement (Volksmusikpflege) has created, over the course of de
cades, a totally transformed sound in contrast to the original models. In t
he mid-1980s the own "Wilden im eigenen Land" (savages in ones own country)
were discovered in the form of traditional village music ensembles. Such b
ands were based on strong family traditions which, until recent decades, do
minated in Bavarian music-making. Using the example of a meter-shifting dan
ce, the author investigates, with the help of detailed transcriptions, what
distinguishes such traditional groups from the newer folk music (in this c
ase, particularly brass music) cultivation groups. The traditional form of
music-making, with its almost forgotten vitality, must simply be judged by
its own standards. This does not mean uniform ensemble playing but rather i
t is the result of a unique musicality acquired over many years that each i
ndividual musician brings to the ensemble.