Context: Misconceptions about STD-protective behaviors have not been studie
d before and after STD counseling. Further, to the best of our knowledge, t
he relationship of these misconceptions to condom use and STD incidence has
not previously been described in published reports.
Objectives: The main purpose of the study was to determine the prevalence o
f misconceptions about STD prevention among STD clinic attendees (N=3498) i
n five large cities, as well as whether misconceptions decreased after STD
diagnosis, STD counseling, or both. The study also identified predictors of
persistent misconceptions and determined the relationship of STD incidence
and unprotected sex to persistent misconceptions.
Methods: Data from a randomized controlled trial evaluating HIV/STD counsel
ing interventions (Project RESPECT) were used for the present analyses. Par
ticipants completed an interview upon study enrollment and every 3 months f
ollowing enrollment for a 1-year period. A portion of the interview assesse
d participants' misconceptions about STD-protective behaviors.
Results: At baseline, 16.3% believed that washing the genitals after sex pr
otected from STDs. Likewise, urinating after sex (38.7%), douching (45.7%),
and use of oral contraceptives (19.9%) were believed to prevent STDs. Prev
alence of misconceptions was significantly diminished at a 3-month follow-u
p (p<.001). Those continuing to have misconceptions were more likely to be
aged greater than or equal to 24 and African American. Those continuing to
have these misconceptions did not have higher STD incidence.
Conclusions: Misconceptions about STD-protective behaviors are common, and
the event of an STD or STD counseling or both generally reduces these misco
nceptions. Although these misconceptions may not directly translate into ri
sky behavior, they may preclude movement toward safer sex.