We explore the implications of an often overlooked fact in community restor
ation: most species, in real or synthetic communities, are infrequent or ra
re, a phenomenon we call "inherent rarity." Whether from long-term interact
ions of many factors affecting birth, death, and establishment within natur
al communities or from short-term interactions of recently created communit
ies species abundance distributions are roughly lognormal or even more atte
nuated. The greater the predisturbance species diversity of remnants or the
planting diversity of restorations, and the smaller the area of a habitat
patch, the more likely a large proportion of species will exist in populati
ons so small that they are acutely or chronically vulnerable to local extin
ction. We suggest that habitat fragmentation will inevitably favor plants a
nd animals that are highly mobile, early successional species, including ma
ny exotic weeds among plants, or,species that are historically organized as
metapopulations that happen to be common enough to function as such. We fu
rther explore rationales for countering the effects of Inherent rarity, inc
luding connectivity from buffers, corridors, and stepping stones, and domin
ance suppression from seasonally appropriate mowing, grating or fire.