Cm. Huang et al., Predictors of short-term outcome in Chinese patients with ambulatory heartfailure for heart transplantation with ejection fraction < 25%, JPN HEART J, 41(3), 2000, pp. 349-369
Heart transplantation (HT) provides longer survival than that of the natura
l history in patients with dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). However, the optim
al timing for cardiac transplantation and predictors of mortality in patien
ts with end-stage cardiomyopathy (ESCM) has been poorly defined. The primar
y purpose of this study focused on the natural history of ambulatory patien
ts with ESCM for HT assessment. Secondly, Lye tried to determine prognostic
factors of individuals with the poorest short-term outcome and the optimal
timing for HT in patients with ESCM. Finally, clinical treatment with angi
otensin converting-enzyme inhibitors (ACEIs), carvedilol and amiodarone in
the prevention of mortality caused by ESCM, were retrospectively evaluated.
The short-term outcomes of 119 referral patients with ESCM for four years w
ere observed. The patients had New York Heart Association class III to IV d
yspnea at initial assessment for HT. Left ventricular ejection fraction (LV
EF) was 17 +/- 6 % and cardiac index (CI) was 2.0 +/- 0.6 l / min / m(2). A
fter optimization of medical treatment, the patients were divided into two
major groups according to CI equal to or less than 2.0 l / min / m(2) and m
ore than 2.0 l / min / m(2). HTs were accepted in 58 patients and the patie
nts were divided into two groups: medical treatment (group 1, 56 patients)
or HT (group 3, 32 patients); HT was not accepted in the other 31 patients
(group 2). We studied the probability of the survival curve and prognostic
variables of the groups with medical treatment in the follow-up of 12 +/- 9
months.
During follow-up, 49 patients were alive without HT. The remaining 38 patie
nts died; 27 patients were in group 1 and 11 patients were in group 2. Eigh
t deaths in group 2 were sudden. The actuarial survival rate among the non-
MT population was 73 %, 68 %, 63 %, and 56 % at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months, resp
ectively. The actuarial survival rate among group 1 was 70 %, 59 %, 55 %, a
nd 52 % at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months, respectively. The actuarial survival rate
among group 2 was 87 %, 85 %, 77 %, and 65 % at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months, res
pectively. A comparison, excluding patients with HT, was performed with tho
se who had survived < 1 year and greater than or equal to 1 year after asse
ssment, and those who had died. Two parameters were independent predictors
of prognosis on univariate and multivariate analysis: total pulmonary vascu
lar resistance (TPR) greater than or equal to 14 Wood units (W) and CI < 1.
65 l / t min m(2) at 6 and 12 months after assessment. Treatment with amiod
arone for ventricular tachycardia (VT) showed no convincing role in the pre
vention of sudden death in our patients. Also, treatment with ACEIs or carv
edilol for heart failure was unconvincing to improve the short-term outcome
in this study.
Our results suggest in properly selected patients that HT should be conside
red within six months among patients with severe heart failure. Hemodynamic
parameters associated with right cardiac function are important determinan
ts of mortality caused by progressive heart failure. Predictors such as CI
and TPR may be considered as important markers of mortality in prediction o
f short-term outcome in patients with ESCM, as other predictors reported in
the literature.