In September 1999 the Independent Commission on Policing irt Northern Irela
nd, chaired by Chris Fatten, published its recommendations. This article ex
amines the political context of policing reform, the contents of the report
and the rejection of its core ideas in the Police (Northern Ireland) Bill
published in May 2000. The central argument of the paper is that the Commis
sion's radical model of policing - a network of regulating mechanisms in wh
ich policing becomes everyone's business failed, because it gave insufficie
nt attention, like much modern writing on policing, to the role of the stat
e and the vested interests within policing. The overall outcome is that the
Fatten Commission has been effectively policed and Northern Ireland will b
e left with a traditional, largely undemocratic and unaccountable model of
policing with most of the control resting with the Secretary of State and t
he Chief Constable.