This paper provides alternative measures of federal budget surpluses over 1
0-year and long-term horizons. Official baseline budget forecasts are based
on a series of statutory requirements that may be at variance with reasona
ble expectation. Move plausible notions of current policy toward discretion
ary spending, taxes, and retirement trust funds imply that surpluses over t
he next 10 years will be substantially smaller than the baseline forecasts
indicate. Properly accounting for long-term imbalances in social security a
nd the vest of the budget implies that, under plausible definitions of curr
ent policy, the federal government faces a long-term shortfall.