Ph. Roche et al., Neurofibromatosis type 2. Preliminary results of gamma knife radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas, NEUROCHIRE, 46(4), 2000, pp. 339-353
Background and purpose. - The aim of this study was to assess tolerance and
efficacy of gamma knife radiosurgery on vestibular schwannomas for patient
s affected with neurofibromatosis type 2.
Methods. - Between July 1992 and December 1997, a gamma knife procedure was
performed on 35 vestibular schwannomas affecting 27 patients (12 females a
nd 15 males, mean age = 27 years-old, range: 14-65). Fifteen of the patient
s were included in the Wishart subtype (severe form) and 12 patients in the
Gardner subtype (mild form). This group of 27 patients represented 8,2 % o
f the total group of vestibular schwannomas radiosurgically treated by our
team. The mean tumor volume was 4 000 mm(3) (range : 400-14 400 mm(3)) and
staging according to Koos classification was 9 stade 2 tumors (extension in
the cerebellopontine angle), 19 stade 3 tumors (in contact with the brain
stem or cerebellum) and 7 stade 4 tumors (compression of axial structures).
The delivered mean marginal dose (50 % isodose) was 13 Gy (range: 10-18 Gy
). After the treatment, the mean clinical and radiological follow-up was 32
months (range: 6-70).
Results. - Twenty six (74 %) of the treated tumors were controlled by the t
reatment (15 stabilisations and II regressions of the tumor volume) at last
follow-lip. One microsurgical removal was required in a growing stade 4 tu
mor and in 2 cases of growing stade 3 tumors. Three post-radiosurgical faci
al nerve deficits (9 %) were observed, 2 of them were transient. According
to the Gardner and Robertson classification, classes I (good) and II (servi
ceable) hearing were preserved at last follow-rip in 57 % of the patients h
aving the same hearing level prior to the gamma knife.
Conclusions. - Our experience confirms that tolerance of gamma knife radios
urgery compares favorably with microsurgery of bilateral vestibular schwann
omas. This treatment should be restricted to small and medium growing tumor
s. Treatment strategy of neurofibromatosis type 2 patients should be planne
d by multidisciplinary experienced teams disposing of the whole armamentari
um A longer follow-lip study is required to confirm the current results reg
arding the tumor control rate.