F. Portier et al., Hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery: indications, techniques and results in the literature since 1990, NEUROCHIRE, 46(4), 2000, pp. 358-368
Many authors have recently reported hearing preservation for approximately
two-thirds of acoustic neuroma patients. The results have driven them to re
commend early surgery for all patients whose hearing might be saved. Invers
ely, other authors advocate that MRI-screening may be beneficial in some pa
tients and suggest surgery only in case of tumor growth or progressive hear
ing loss.
In order to facilitate therapeutic decision making, we reviewed the techniq
ues and results in the main papers dealing with hearing preservation in the
course of acoustic neuroma surgery published since 1990. This analysis sho
wed that the average percentage of useful hearing preservation is about 31
%. It is however difficult to compare the different series due to the diffe
rent methodologies used This emphasizes the need for standardization of hea
ring selection and reporting criteria to a) identify factors predictive of
success (tumor characteristics, preoperative hearing, monitoring, surgical
pathways), and b) elaborate well accepted decisional guidelines (early surg
ery or MRI screening), notably for small and non-symptomatic tumors which s
how increasing prevalence.