Background. The use of organs from non-heart-beating donors (NHBDs) has bee
n proposed as one way to increase the donor pool. However; few centers have
transplanted livers from NHBDs. We report here the results of 19 liver tra
nsplants from controlled NHBDs.
Methods. From January 1993 through August 1999, 364 liver transplantations
were performed from heart-beating donors (HBDs) and 19 liver transplantatio
ns were performed from NHBDs. Donor and recipient characteristics, posttran
splant complications, and patient and allograft survival were compared.
Results. No differences in hepatic artery, portal vein, or biliary complica
tions were noted between the groups. However, the rate of primary nonfuncti
on was higher in recipients of liver-from NHBDs (10.5% vs 1.3%; P =.04). No
difference in patient survival was seen between recipients of NHBDs or HBD
s (72.6% vs 84.8%; P =.36); however, allograft survival was lower in recipi
ents who received livers from NHBDs (53.8% vs 80.9%; P =.007).
Conclusions. Liver transplantation from controlled NHBDs results in similar
patient survival and posttransplant complications. However; primary nonfun
ction was higher and allograft survival was less in recipients of livers fr
om NHBDs. The results of liver transplantation from controlled NHBDs are en
couraging and should continue to be cautiously pursued as one way to help a
lleviate the current shortage of donor livers.