We examine the observational consequences of the two possible origins for i
rregular galaxies: formation from collapse of a primordial cloud of gas ear
ly in the age of the universe, or formation from tidal tails in an interact
ion that could have occurred any time in the history of the universe. Becau
se the formation from tidal tails could have occurred a long time ago, prox
imity to larger galaxies is not sufficient to distinguish tidal dwarfs from
traditional dwarfs. We consider the effects of little or no dark matter on
rotation speeds and the Tully-Fisher relationship, the metallicity-luminos
ity relationship, structure, and stellar populations. From these selection
criteria, we identify a small list of dwarf irregular galaxies that are can
didates for having formed as tidal dwarfs.