Sa. Barkovic et al., A clinical evaluation of a glycolic acid hand treatment with retinyl palmitate and an SPF 15 on photoaged hand skin, J DERM TR, 11(3), 2000, pp. 165-172
BACKGROUND: The backs of the hands are typically unprotected from sunlight,
and therefore prone to photodamage. Corrective invasive procedures such as
chemical peeling and laser resurfacing are not recommended for the hand ow
ing to the thinness of dorsal hand skin, and constant hand movement, and th
erefore, a therapeutic lotion has been developed as a treatment alternative
.
AIM: To evaluate the safety and efficacy of a therapeutic hand lotion compa
red with a usual hand and body lotion over a 12-week period to improve the
appearance of photoaged hand skin,
METHODS: A hand treatment containing glycolic acid and retinyl palmitate wi
th a sunscreen (SPF 15) was developed, and compared with a usual hand and b
ody lotion (control) in a double-blind, 12-week, paired-comparison study (r
ight hand versus left hand). Evaluations included clinical grading for effi
cacy and irritation, instrumental measurements, and subject self-assessment
s of product benefit. Changes in appearance during the test period were doc
umented by clinical scientific digital imaging. in all, 75% of the panel ra
ted the overall product performance as 'excellent' or 'very good', indicati
ng high self-perceived benefit and user acceptance.
RESULTS: The hand treatment was significantly more effective (p less than o
r equal to0.05) ill improving skin clarity, crepy texture, and overall phot
oaged appearance compared with control at all time points in the study. Add
itionally, the test product was superior to control in pinch recoil (skin r
esiliency) measurements by 8 weeks of usage. This effect was confirmed by s
ignificant improvement in Cutometer(R) measurements of resiliency by week 1
2. The test product was found to significantly increase skin moisture conte
nt over baseline. This effect was corroborated by significant reductions in
self-perceived skin tightness (subjective irritation) and stratum corneum
flaking parameters (Squame(R) disk analysis).
CONCLUSION: The therapeutic hand lotion developed was shown to be safe and
possess superior effectiveness to a usual hand and body lotion for ameliora
ting many of the symptoms of photodamage.