T. Linkosalo et al., Predicting spring phenology and frost damage risk of Betula spp. under climatic warming: a comparison of two models, TREE PHYSL, 20(17), 2000, pp. 1175-1182
Timing of bud burst and frost damage risk for leaves of Betula spp. in resp
onse to climatic warming in Finland was examined with two models. In the fi
rst model, ontogenetic development in spring was triggered by an accumulati
on of chilling temperatures. The second model assumed an additional signal
from the light climate. The two models gave radically different estimates o
f frost damage risk in response to climate warming. The chilling-triggered
model forecast a significant and increasing risk with increased warming, wh
ereas the light-climate-triggered model predicted little or no risk.
The chilling-triggered model is widely applied in phenological research; ho
wever, there is increasing experimental evidence that light conditions play
a role in the timing of spring phenology. Although it is not clear if the
light response mechanisms are appropriately represented in our model, the r
esults imply that reliance on a light signal for spring development would a
fford a degree of protection against possible frost damage under climate wa
rming that would not be present if chilling were the sole determinant. Furt
her experimental tests are required to ascertain the light-related mechanis
ms controlling phenological timing, so that credible model extrapolations c
an be undertaken.