Kibble and Zurek have provided a unifying causal picture for the appearance
of classical defects like cosmic strings or vortices at the onset of phase
transitions in relativistic QFT and condensed matter systems, respectively
. In condensed matter the predictions are partially supported by agreement
with experiments in superfluid helium. We provide an alternative picture fo
r the initial appearance of defects that supports the experimental evidence
. When the original predictions fail, this is understood, in part, as a con
sequence of thermal fluctuations (noise), which play a comparable role in b
oth condensed matter and QFT.