Re. Larsen et al., INSTANTANEOUS PERSPECTIVES ON SOLUTE RELAXATION IN FLUIDS - THE COMMON ORIGINS OF NONPOLAR SOLVATION DYNAMICS AND VIBRATIONAL POPULATION RELAXATION, The Journal of chemical physics, 107(2), 1997, pp. 524-543
The basic idea that the instantaneous normal modes of a fluid govern i
ts short-time dynamics has recently been used to arrive at theories fo
r solvation dynamics and for vibrational population relaxation, theori
es not quite as distinct as one might have guessed for such different-
looking relaxation processes.-Both theories, in particular, revolve ar
ound the weighted spectra of instantaneous normal modes we call the in
fluence spectra, with the distinctions between the different problems
showing up largely in the different weightings. We show in this paper
that the influence spectra reveal a surprising amount of commonality i
n these two processes. For the models we consider, involving an atomic
solvent and relatively short-ranged intermolecular forces, the two ki
nds of averaged influence spectra have virtually identical shapes. Mor
eover, examining a single configuration of the fluid at a time reveals
that both spectra are strongly inhomogeneously broadened - that is, r
elatively few modes contribute at any instant, despite the breadth of
the configurationally averaged spectra. What is apparently responsible
for this common behavior is yet a deeper similarity. If one focuses s
pecifically on the contributing modes, it becomes clear that the reaso
n they contribute is their ability to move one or two solvent atoms in
the immediate vicinity of the solute. This observation implies that i
t should always be possible for us to construct a set of effective mod
es involving motions that would be no more elaborate than few-body vib
rations but that would still allow us to predict the influence spectra
. We demonstrate just such predictions in this paper, using the one or
two simple binary modes which vibrate the solute against its nearest-
neighbor solvent atom. Binary modes as a class account for no more tha
n the highest 10% of the instantaneous-normal-mode frequencies, yet we
find that the solute-solvent binary modes are not only responsible fo
r all of the high frequency aspects of solvation dynamics and vibratio
nal population relaxation, they account in a quantitative sense for th
e majority of both influence spectra. At least in these examples, the
bulk of the mechanism by which short-time relaxation takes place is ev
idently no more complicated than pair motions - what the rest of the s
olvent decides is how and when these motions take place. (C) 1997 Amer
ican Institute of Physics.