R. Kerschbamer et G. Kirchsteiger, Theoretically robust but empirically invalid? An experimental investigation into tax equivalence, ECON THEORY, 16(3), 2000, pp. 719-734
The idea that the final distribution of the tax burden (economic incidence)
does not depend on the initial distribution of tax liabilities (statutory
incidence) is referred to as the Liability Side Equivalence principle. This
paper tests this principle in the laboratory and finds that subjects who a
ctually have to pay the tax carry a higher tax burden. It is argued that th
is violation of Liability Side Equivalence is due to the fact that a change
in the distribution of tax liabilities induces a shift in behaviorally rel
evant social norms. This shift, in turn, affects the impact of the tax. Our
results explain some striking empirical observations and have important th
eoretical and practical implications.