R. Weber et al., Serological and clinical evidence for human granulocytic ehrlichiosis in north-eastern Switzerland, SCHW MED WO, 130(41), 2000, pp. 1462-1470
Background: Tick-borne human granulocytic ehrlichiosis (HGE) has not been d
iagnosed in Switzerland, although the HGE agent has been identified in tick
s and animal reservoirs and human infections have been suspected on the bas
is of serological surveys.
Methods: We retrospectively tested sera of 48 persons with antibodies to B.
burgdorferi and/or tick-borne encephalitis virus for the presence of antib
odies to E. phagocytophila (a surrogate marker of the agent of HGE), and re
viewed their charts with regard to clinical manifestations possibly associa
ted with a tick-borne infection. We then prospectively examined EDTA blood
of 80 patients who presented with fever 7 to 21 days after a tick bite for
the presence of the HGE agent (using nested PCR and microscopic examination
of blood smears) and anti-E. phagocytophila antibodies. We also collected
clinical data.
Results: The retrospective study revealed 12 persons (25%) with anti-E. pha
gocytophila antibody titers greater than or equal to1:80, suggesting coinfe
ction with HGE and either Lyme Borrelia or tick-borne encephalitis virus. A
mong these, 7 patients presented with clinical manifestations compatible wi
th HGE disease. The prospective investigation identified 8 patients (10%) w
ith anti-E. phagocytophila antibody titers greater than or equal to1:80, an
d 7 of these presented with signs and symptoms suggesting HGE. The HGE agen
t, however, was detected neither by PCR nor by microscopic examination.
Conclusions: Serological and clinical data suggest die occurrence of an HGE
-like agent as well as of coinfections with HGE and B. burgdorferi or tick-
borne encephalitis virus in Switzerland. However, the HGE agent was not ide
ntified in persons living in Switzerland.