We synthesize the results of empirical studies of marine reserves to assess
the potential benefits of protection for fish populations. Our meta-analys
es demonstrate that the overall abundance of fishes inside reserves is, on
average, 3.7 times higher than outside reserve boundaries. This enhancement
is mainly a result of a significant increase in abundance of species that
are the target of fisheries. Non-target species are equally abundant inside
and outside reserves. Large-bodied species also respond more to protection
, irrespective of their fishery status. Species within genera show great he
terogeneity in their response to protection despite similarities in their l
ife histories. Our study confirms that marine reserves benefit fish populat
ions and highlights the need for monitoring prior to reserve establishment
to provide more accurate, habitat-controlled studies of the effects of mari
ne reserves on fish populations.