Cl. Shields et al., Conjunctival melanoma - Risk factors for recurrence, exenteration, metastasis, and death in 150 consecutive patients, ARCH OPHTH, 118(11), 2000, pp. 1497-1507
Objective: To identify the risk factors of conjunctival malignant melanoma
that predict local tumor recurrence, orbital exenteration, distant metastas
is, and tumor-related mortality.
Design: The clinical parameters of the patient, tumor, and treatment were a
nalyzed in a nonrandomized fashion for their relation to 4 main outcome mea
sures using Cox proportional hazards regression models.
Participants: One hundred fifty consecutive patients.
Main Outcome Measures: Local tumor recurrence, orbital exenteration, distan
t metastasis, and death from conjunctival melanoma.
Results: The Kaplan-Meier estimates of local tumor recurrence was 26% at 5
years, 51% at 10 years, and 65% at 15 years. The mean number of recurrences
per patient was 1 (median, 0 recurrences). There was no recurrence in 98 p
atients (65%), 1 recurrence in 28 patients (19%), 2 recurrences in 11 patie
nts (7%), 3 recurrences in 5 patients (3%), and 4 or more recurrences in 8
patients (5%). Using multivariate analysis, the factors correlated with loc
al tumor recurrence were melanoma location (not touching the limbus) (P=.01
) and pathological tumor margins (lateral margin involved) (P=.02). Multiva
riate analysis for features correlated with ultimate exenteration included
initial visual acuity (20/40 OU or worse) (P<.001), melanoma color red (P=.
01), and melanoma location (not touching the limbus) (P=.02).
Tumor metastasis was present in 16% of patients at 5 years, 26% of patients
at 10 years, and 32% of patients at 15 years. Metastasis was first located
in the regional lymph nodes in 17 cases, the brain in 4 cases, the liver i
n 3 cases, the lung in 2 cases, and was disseminated in 1 case. The risks f
or metastases using multivariate analysis included pathological tumor margi
ns (lateral margin involved) (P=.002) and melanoma location (not touching l
imbus) (P=.04).
Tumor-related death occurred in 7% patients at 5 years' follow-up and 13% a
t 8 years' follow-up. The risk factors for death using multivariate analysi
s included initial symptoms (lump) (P=.004) and pathologic findings (de nov
o melanoma without primary acquired melanosis) (P=.05). The technique of in
itial surgery was shown to be an important factor in preventing eventual tu
mor recurrence (P=.07), metastasis (P=.03), and death (P=.006) in the univa
riate analysis, but did not reach significance in the multivariate analysis
.
Conclusions: Conjunctival malignant melanoma is a potentially deadly tumor.
In the present study, metastasis was detected in 26% of patients, and deat
h occurred in 13% of patients at 10 years. Extralimbal melanoma and tumor i
nvolvement of the surgical margins were especially poor prognostic factors.
Meticulous surgical planning using wide microsurgical excisional biopsy wo
rking with the "no touch" technique and supplemental alcohol corneal epithe
liectomy and conjunctival cryotherapy is advised.