Ea. Robinson et al., REINTERPRETATION OF THE LENGTHS OF BONDS TO FLUORINE IN TERMS OF AN ALMOST IONIC MODEL, Inorganic chemistry, 36(14), 1997, pp. 3022-3030
We have calculated the electron density distributions, electron densit
ies at the bond critical point, and atomic charges in the period 2 and
3 fluorides and a number of their cations and anions. On the basis of
this information and an analysis of X-F bond lengths, we have examine
d the factors that determine the lengths of these bonds. We have shown
that all the molecules except NF3, Of(2), and F-2 have considerable i
onic character. The bond lengths of the fluorides reach a minimum valu
e at BF3 in period 2 and at SiF4 in period 3 when the product of the c
harges on the central atom and a fluorine reaches a maximum, consisten
t with a predominately ionic model for these fluorides. The length of
a given A-F bond decreases with decreasing coordination number, and we
show that it is determined primarily by packing considerations. This
provides an alternative to the previously proposed back-bonding model
explanation, for which our work provides no convincing evidence. There
is also no evidence to support the Schomaker-Stevenson equation which
has been widely used to correct A-F bond lengths calculated from the
sum of the covalent radii of A and F for the difference in the electro
negativities of A and F. We propose a new value for the covalent radiu
s of fluorine and point out the limitations of its use.