K. Knickel et H. Renting, Methodological and conceptual issues in the study of multifunctionality and rural development, SOCIOL RUR, 40(4), 2000, pp. 512
The aim of this paper is to try and outline the complexity of rural develop
ment processes that specifically relate to the phenomenon of multifunctiona
lity. 'Multifunctionality schemes' are introduced as a means for visualizin
g the complex interrelationships in rural development processes and to 'map
' the functional relationships and specific reconfigurations in the use of
resources such as land, labour, knowledge and nature that underlie them. In
the discussion, reference is made to case studies from the IMPACT research
programme. The Rhongold case is used to illustrate how ME-schemes can help
to define micro-macro relations and facilitate their quantification. Sever
al conceptual issues are addressed in relation to the translation of farm d
ata to the regional level, indirect multiplier effects, substitution effect
s and the importance of synergy. Methodological complications are seen in p
roblems associated with the acceptance of a paradigm shift; the inadequacy
of available regional, national and European data sets; the complex nature
of micro-macro relations; the difficulty of defining boundaries and referen
ce systems; and the struggle with time, scale and space as critical modifie
rs of reality. The need to link the dimensions of agricultural and rural ch
ange demands a more multidisciplinary, holistic approach to analysis and co
nceptualization.