Th. Rainer et al., Cost effectiveness analysis of intravenous ketorolac and morphine for treating pain after limb injury: double blind randomised controlled trial, BR MED J, 321(7271), 2000, pp. 1247-1251
Citations number
53
Categorie Soggetti
General & Internal Medicine","Medical Research General Topics
Objectives To investigate the cost effectiveness of intravenous ketorolac c
ompared with intravenous morphine in relieving pain after blunt limb injury
in an accident and emergency department.
Design Double blind, randomised, controlled study and cost consequences ana
lysis.
Setting Emergency department of a university hospital in the New Territorie
s of Hong Kong.
Participants 148 adult patients with painful isolated limb injuries (limb i
njuries without other injuries).
Main outcome measures Primary outcome measure was a cost consequences analy
sis comparing the use of ketorolac with morphines; secondary outcome measur
es were pain relief at rest and with limb movement, adverse events, patient
s' satisfaction, and time spent in the emergency department.
Results No difference was found in the median time taken to achieve pain re
lief at rest between the group receiving ketorolac and the group receiving
morphine, but with movement the median reduction in pain score in the ketor
olac group was 1.09 per hour (95% confidence interval 1.05 to 2.02) compare
d with 0.87 (0.89 to 1.06) in the morphine group (P = 0.003). The odds of e
xperiencing adverse events was 144.2 (41.5 to 501.6) times more likely with
morphine than with ketorolac. The median time from the initial delivery of
analgesia to the participant leaving the department was 20 (4.0 to 39.0) m
inutes shorter in the ketorolac group, than in the morphine group (P = 0.02
). The mean cost per person was $HK44 (pound4; $5.6) in the ketorolac group
and $HK229 in the morphine group (P < 9.0001). The median score for patien
ts' satisfaction was 6.0 for ketorolac and 5.0 for morphine (P < 0.0001).
Conclusion Intravenous ketorolac is a more cost effective analgesic than in
travenous morphine in the management of isolated limb injury in all emergen
cy department in Hong Kong, and its use may be considered as the dominant s
trategy.