Dm. Stein et al., Diversification in the presence of taxes - There are substantial risks incurred with concentrated holdings., J PORTFOLIO, 27(1), 2000, pp. 61
A common problem for taxable investors is how much to diversify either a lo
w cost basis single-asset or concentrated portfolio. While tax-exempt theor
y is clear on the benefits of diversification, and there are useful industr
y methods for addressing this, in the presence of taxes there are no standa
rd approaches to arriving at a considered choice. The authors propose an an
alytic and intuitive framework for addressing the problem, considering only
two investment alternatives. By defining a tax-deferred equivalent of the
taxable investor, they are able to adapt standard analytical methods and vi
ew the diversification decision in the presence of taxes as a conventional
risk-return trade-off, provided the appropriate tax-deferred performance me
asures are used. Greater diversification is needed with greater initial ass
et volatility, with longer investment horizons, with lower expected return
of the initial asset, and with a higher cost basis. Less diversification is
needed when the investor receives a step-up in basis at the horizon. The r
esults highlight the substantial risks incurred in concentrated holdings an
d often support high levels of diversification, even in the face of taxes.