Among the non-parametric approaches to defining and testing the hypothesis
of no interactions in a two-way design, the method by Patel and Heel is app
ealing because it is a function of the ranks and therefore invariant under
monotonic increasing transformations of the data, and it does not require t
he assumption of no main effects fur the approach to be valid, Recently, Wi
lcox compared three different methods for implementing their method, each m
ethod differing in how the appropriate standard error is estimated. In term
s of Type I errors, only one of the methods gave satisfactory results in si
mulations, but it assumes there are no tied values. Cliff has considered th
e problem of tied values in detail, and his results are easily extended to
the problem considered by Wilcox. This paper describes this extension and c
ompares it to the method recommended by Wilcox.