Many studies have shown that government debt auctions underprice debt compa
red with the secondary market. This paper corroborates this for certain for
ms of gilt auction by comparing the price received at auction with an almos
t identical parent stock in the secondary market. Although the sample is sm
all, the parent/auction stock price comparison gives a cleaner measure than
used in other studies. The paper also compares non-fungible auctions (wher
e the auction stock differs slightly from the parent at auction and merges
subsequently) with fully-fungible ones (where they are identical throughout
). Significant underpricing only occurs in non-fungible auctions.