M. Mon-williams et Ah. Murray, The size of the visual size cue used for programming manipulative forces during precision grip, EXP BRAIN R, 135(3), 2000, pp. 405-410
We used a perturbation technique to quantify the contribution of visual siz
e cues to the programming of target force when lifting an object. Our resul
ts indicate that the nervous system attaches a reasonable weight to visual
size cues when programming the target grip force for a novel object. In a s
ubsequent lift of the same object, however, the confidence attached to the
visual size cue fell dramatically. It is not clear whether the decrease in
the use of size information was accelerated by the presence of a cue confli
ct or whether the fall represents the normal shift towards the use of a mem
ory-based representation for programming grip force. In a second experiment
, we used the "size-weight illusion" to explore the relationship between th
e verbal report of an object's weight and the programming of the grip and l
oad force. We found that erroneous motor programming (as indexed by a numbe
r of measures) was neither necessary nor sufficient for the size-weight ill
usion to occur. These findings call for a re-evaluation of a previous expla
nation for the size-weight illusion. We suggest that the illusion arises be
cause the cognitive system attempts to rationalise the fact that objects of
apparently equal density but different size feel as if they have the same
weight.