The temporal relations among candidate causes were studied in a causal indu
ction task using a design that is known to produce occasion setting in anim
al learning preparations. For some subset of the observations, one event, t
he occasion setter, was accompanied by another event, the conditional cause
; for another subset of the observations, the conditional cause occurred al
one. The efficacy of the conditional cause depended on whether it was or wa
s not accompanied by the occasion setter. Participants used the occasion se
tter to modulate their effect expectancy to the conditional cause when the
events were presented serially, but not simultaneously. Current causal indu
ction models are unable to account for the full range of effects that we ob
served; the relative roles of time, attention, and cue distinctiveness are
discussed.