This paper reports the results of a study of free association in which part
icipants were asked to produce the first two words to come to mind. The fin
dings were used to estimate the reliability of indices of strength and set
size for different types of items and to model free association as a retrie
val task. When confined to first responses, reliability was generally high
for both indices, particularly for words with smaller sets of associates an
d stronger primaries. When second responses were included, reliability decl
ined. A second response added new but weak items to the set, and, when the
primary associate was not produced on the first opportunity, it bended not
to be produced on the second. Relative to when multiple responses are reque
sted, first-response free association provides more reliable indices of the
relative strength and set size for a word's strongest associates. A model
of free association assuming that a strength distribution underlies each re
sponse provided a good fit to the data.