A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON THE ZOOGEOGRAPHY OF THE SIBLING MOUSE-EARED BAT SPECIES MYOTIS-MYOTIS AND MYOTIS-BLYTHII - MORPHOLOGICAL, GENETIC AND ECOLOGICAL EVIDENCE
R. Arlettaz et al., A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON THE ZOOGEOGRAPHY OF THE SIBLING MOUSE-EARED BAT SPECIES MYOTIS-MYOTIS AND MYOTIS-BLYTHII - MORPHOLOGICAL, GENETIC AND ECOLOGICAL EVIDENCE, Journal of zoology, 242, 1997, pp. 45-62
The actual geographic distribution of the two sibling mouse-eared bat
species Myotis myotis and Myotis blythii, which occur widely sympatric
ally in the western Palaearctic region, remains largely controversial.
This concerns particularly the specific attribution of marginal popul
ations from the Mediterranean islands and from adjacent areas of North
Africa and Asia, which are morphologically intermediate between conti
nental M. myotis and M. blythii from Europe. This study attempts to cl
arify this question by using four different approaches: cranial morpho
logy, external morphology, genetics and trophic ecology. The three lat
ter methods show unambiguously that North Africa, Malta, Sardinia and
Corsica are presently inhabited by monospecific populations of M. myot
is. In contrast, cranial morphometrics do not yield conclusive results
. These results contradict all recent studies, which attribute North A
frican and Maltese mouse-eared bats to M. blythii and consider that Sa
rdinia and Corsica harbour sympatric populations of the two species. A
s concerns south-eastern populations, doubts are also expressed about
the attribution of the subspecific taxon omari which may actually refe
r to M. myotis instead of M. blythii. Protein electrophoresis is prese
ntly the only absolute method available for determining M. myotis and
M. blythii throughout their distribution ranges. However, species iden
tification may be approached by relying on less sophisticated morphome
trical methods as presented in this study. Species-specific habitat sp
ecializations are probably responsible for the differences observed be
tween the geographic distributions of M. myotis and M. blythii, as the
y provide a logical groundwork for a coherent model of speciation for
these two bat species.