Parallels between statistical issues in medical and meteorological experimentation

Authors
Citation
Kr. Gabriel, Parallels between statistical issues in medical and meteorological experimentation, J APPL MET, 39(11), 2000, pp. 1822-1836
Citations number
57
Categorie Soggetti
Earth Sciences
Journal title
JOURNAL OF APPLIED METEOROLOGY
ISSN journal
08948763 → ACNP
Volume
39
Issue
11
Year of publication
2000
Pages
1822 - 1836
Database
ISI
SICI code
0894-8763(200011)39:11<1822:PBSIIM>2.0.ZU;2-S
Abstract
The methodology of experimentation, randomization, and statistical analysis in weather modification has many parallels in clinical trials, such as the need for randomization and the question of inclusion or exclusion of units assigned to be treated but not actually treated. There also are considerab le differences, mainly in the definition of units, where the obvious choice of a single patient is in contrast with the highly problematic definition of a cloud or storm, and in the ethical aspects. This paper highlights some of these parallels and differences in the hope that looking at one's own p roblems in a different context may enhance one's understanding. It may also reconcile experimenters to their need for statistics: as the Hebrew saying goes, "Tzarat rabim, hatzi nehama" (the misfortune of many is half a conso lation).