This article presents a detailed simulation study of the highest achievable
voltage ratings on bi-directional semiconductor controlled rectifiers desi
gned using wide band-gap materials. It is shown that the voltage ratings of
4H-SiC and GaN are limited by small carrier lifetimes, as a result of mate
rial defects or crystal structure. Symmetric thyristors rated up to 8 kV ar
e possible with commercially available 4H-SiC wafers that have carrier life
times longer than 300 ns. With further improvements in wafer quality, devic
es with voltage rating higher than 15 kV may be achievable. The performance
of 8 kV 4H-SiC thyristors is compared with that of 8 kV Si thyristors. It
is shown that the on-state voltage of 4H-SiC thyristors has very little dep
endence on temperature up to 300 degreesC unlike Si thyristors, with a posi
tive temperature coefficient. Finally, simulations suggest that symmetric G
aN thyristors may be impractical primarily because of the low carrier lifet
imes resulting from direct band structure. (C) 2000 American Institute of P
hysics. [S0021-8979(00)03901-9].