Cw. Honeycutt, QUANTIFYING TOTAL, N, AND NON-N RELATED CROP-ROTATION EFFECTS WITHOUTN-15, Biological agriculture & horticulture, 14(2), 1997, pp. 125-137
The N benefits attributed to legumes in crop rotations are often overe
stimated because the technique for quantifying this benefit without N-
15 includes rotation effects not directly related to N. This study was
conducted to test an approach proposed in the literature for delineat
ing such effects without requiring the use of N-15. Potato (Solanum tu
berosum L, cv. Norwis) was grown continuously and in two-year rotation
s with alfalfa (Medicago saliva L. cv. Nitro), hairy vetch (Vicia vill
osa Roth), or white lupin (Lupinus albus L, cv. Ultra). Potato was fer
tilized with 0, 90, or 180 kg N ha(-1) as (NH4)(2)SO4. The total, N, a
nd non-N effects of crop rotation were calculated based on tuber dry w
eight and plant N uptake for the rotation systems and the tuber dry we
ight vs. plant N uptake relationship for continuous potato. The total
effect of crop rotation generally declined upon increasing N fertilize
r from 0 to 90 kg N ha(-1), apparently due to decreasing importance of
the N effect with added fertilizer. Non-N related effects mostly rema
ined static across fertilization regimes. Those effects attributed to
N generally declined upon adding 90 kg N ha(-1) in a relatively dry ye
ar; and upon adding 90 and 180 kg N ha(-1) in a year with more favorab
le precipitation. Calculated N effects with no N fertilizer reflected
the quantity and quality of legume crop residues. This method does all
ow assessment of total, N, and non-N related rotation effects. However
, the approach appears sensitive to climatic conditions, and data shou
ld only be subjected to analysis where a yield response to N exists.