Renal cell carcinoma (RCC), although occurring less frequently than prostat
e and bladder cancer, is actually the most malignant urologic disease, kill
ing >35% of affected patients. Therefore, investigation of the nature of pr
emalignant lesions of the kidney is a relevant issue. Following the most re
cent histological classification RCC can be subdivided into four categories
: conventional RCC: papillary RCC; chromophobe RCC; and collecting duct car
cinoma.
In contrast to many genitourinary malignancies, premalignant alterations in
the kidney an scarcely described. Intratubular epithelial dysplasia has be
en recognized as the most common precursor of RCC. In analogy to prostatic
intraepithelial neoplasia (PIN), the premalignant lesions of the kidney are
described as high or low-grade renal intratubular neoplasia. In contrast,
precancerous lesions have been described as part of the von Hippel-Lindau s
yndrome (VHL) where the evolution from a simple cyst to an atypical cyst wi
th epithelial hyperplasia to cystic or solid conventional-type RCC is well
documented. Finally, in the genesis of papillary RCC an adenoma-carcinoma s
equence has been recognized with specific genetic changes. There are no dat
a on the epidemiology of premalignant lesions of the kidney, but research i
nto the etiology of RCC has been extended substantially. Familial and genet
ic factors are well documented in VHL disease, in hereditary papillary RCC,
in the tuberous sclerosis complex and in familial RCC. Cigarette smoking a
nd obesity are established risk factors for RCC. Hypertension or its medica
tion has also been associated with an increased risk. Among dietary factors
an inverse relation between risk and consumption of vegetables and fruit h
as been found. Occupational exposure to substances such as asbestos and sol
vents has been linked to an increased risk of RCC.
Specific RCC variants have distinctive chromosome alterations and several g
enes have been implicated in the development of RCC. Loss of material from
the 3p chromosome characterizes conventional RCC and the deletion of the VH
L suppressor gene plays an important role in the genesis of this RCC varian
t, in contrast, numerical changes with trisomy of chromosomes 7 and 17 and
loss of the sex chromosome are typical changes in papillary tumors, whereas
papillary RCC have additional trisomies. Chromophobe RCC is characterized
by loss of chromosomes with a combination of monosomies. Less consistent ge
netic alterations are associated with collecting duct carcinoma.
The traditional treatment of RCC is surgery by radical or partial nephrecto
my. The latter approach carries a risk of tumor recurrence as a result of u
nrecognized satellite lesions or premalignant lesions that might have been
present at the time of surgery. However, the reported recurrence rates afte
r partial nephrectomy are <1% and therefore the possible presence of premal
ignant disease does not after the actual treatment strategy advocated. Alth
ough multifocality and bilateral occurrence of RCC are much more Likely in
cases of papillary RCC, biopsy of the renal remnant or contralateral kidney
is not justified even in patients with this tumor type. Conversely, patien
ts with RIN in a partial or radical nephrectomy specimen or in a renal biop
sy taken for whatever reason should be subjected to closer follow-up with r
egularly repeated ultrasound.
When an effective chemopreventive regimen becomes available it might be use
ful for patients with an inherited risk of RCC as well as in those who are
at risk of tumor recurrence after intervention. Mass screening with the pur
pose of detecting RCC at its earliest stage is not recommended at the prese
nt time, but screening focused on certain risk groups can be advocated. Fur
ther research is needed to identify avoidable risks, develop effective chem
oprevention and recognize patients at risk.