R. Frankenberg et al., Countering essentialism in behavioural social science: the example of 'thevulnerable child' ethnographically examined, SOCIOL REV, 48(4), 2000, pp. 586-611
After discussing ways in which the concept of vulnerability is applied to c
hildren in psychology and sociology. It is argued that many of these may ar
ise from the mistaken concretisation of essentialising concepts which have
sometimes thereby become barriers to, rather than facilitators of, sociolog
ical understanding. Fieldwork is presented and analysed concerning the inte
ractions of some London children, and their characterisations of themselves
and others, in a variety of home, school and other settings. It is suggest
ed that situations in which children are present often do generate 'vulnera
bility' in all participants not only in the children. In classrooms and els
ewhere the attribution and reality of vulnerability moves rapidly between p
ersons as situations develop and change.