Reflective practice and the value of reflexivity between personal experienc
e and pedagogy are common research themes today. However, teacher candidate
s often report a lack of encouragement to be reflective of their experience
s with disability and the ways those experiences can inform pedagogy. This
article results from a year of inquiry involving 3 novice teachers with dis
abilities. The impact of their experiences is discussed in light of their d
eveloping pedagogical knowledge. The article concludes that for them, teach
ing is an encounter with the self but that their encounters are an untapped
resource with rich potential for the construction of pedagogical knowledge
. The article argues that teacher educators must facilitate reflection on e
xperiences with disability as with gender, race/ethnicity, and other identi
ty markers or lived experiences. The article includes examples of the autho
r's attempts to make use of disability experiences in the teacher education
curriculum.