Aj. Naldrett, KEY FACTORS IN THE GENESIS OF NORILSK, SUDBURY, JINCHUAN, VOISEY BAY AND OTHER WORLD-CLASS NI-CU-PGE DEPOSITS - IMPLICATIONS FOR EXPLORATION, Australian journal of earth sciences, 44(3), 1997, pp. 283-315
Magmatic Ni-Cu sulfide deposits form as the result of the segregation
and concentration of droplets of liquid sulfide from mafic or ultramaf
ic magma and the partitioning of chalcophile elements into these from
the silicate melt. Sulfide saturation of a magma is not enough in itse
lf to produce a massive concentration of magmatic sulfide. The appropr
iate physical environment is required to concentrate sulfides from a l
arge mass of magma into one place. The deposits of the Noril'sk region
have developed within flat, elongate bodies (15 X 2 X 0.2 km) that in
trude argillites, evaporites and coal measures, adjacent to a major, t
ranscrustal fault and immediately below the centre of a 3.5 km-thick v
olcanic basin. An anticlinal axis that transects the axis of the basin
at a high angle has brought these intrusions to surface to give rise
to the two major ore junctions, Noril'sk and Talnakh. Studies of the o
verlying basalts have shown that basalts forming a 500 m-thick sequenc
e have lost 75% of their Cu and Ni and more than 90% of their PGE. Bas
alts above this show a gradual recovery in their chalcophile element c
oncentrations to reach 'normal' values 500 m above the highly depleted
zone. Two groups of mineralised bodies have been identified as correl
ative with these basalts: the poorly mineralised Lower Talnakh-type bo
dies, which resemble the highly depleted basalts; and the ore-bearing
Noril'sk-type intrusions which correlate with the overlying, essential
ly undepleted basalts. The high proportion of sulfide (2-10 wt%) assoc
iated with the Noril'sk-type intrusions, the high PGE content of the o
res, the extensive metamorphic aureole (100-400 m around the bodies),
and the heavy sulfur isotopic composition of the ores (+8 to +12 delta
(34)S) are explicable if the ore-bearing bodies are exit conduits from
high-level intrusions, along which magma has flowed en route to surfa
ce. The Lower Talnakh bodies are interpreted as intrusions along which
magma flow stopped earlier than along those of the Noril'sk type. The
first magma to enter the high-level intrusion reacted with much evapo
ritic sulfur, at a low 'R' value and thus gave rise to sulfides with l
ow metal tenors. Successive pulses of magma through the system progres
sively enriched the sulfides in the conduits, losing progressively les
s of their chalcophile metals, and thus accounting for the upward incr
ease in metals in successive lava flows. The flow direction along the
conduits is shown by the direction in which the tenor of disseminated
sulfides decreases. Sulfides have settled from the moving magma to for
m separate injections of liquid sulfide, up to 3.5 X 1.5 X 0.05 km in
size. Recent reflection seismic studies at Sudbury have shown the Sudb
ury Igneous complex to have been much more extensive than originally s
upposed. Nd and Sr isotopic studies on rocks of the Sudbury Igneous Co
mplex and Re-Os studies on the ores have indicated the incorporation o
f much country rock gneiss in the complex. Debate has centred around w
hether the Sudbury Igneous Complex is entirely an impact melt or the c
onsequence of the mixing of primary magma with 50 or more wt% impact m
elt; the most recent evidence favours the latter hypothesis. The Jinch
uan deposit of north-central China occurs within a 6 km-long dyke-like
body of peridotite. The compositions of olivine within the dyke, the
igneous rocks themselves, and the ore are all inconsistent with deriva
tion of the body from ultramafic magma, as originally supposed, and in
dicate that the structure forms the keel of a much larger intrusion of
magnesian basalt. Flow of magma into the intrusion has resulted in ol
ivine and sulfide being retained within this keel. The Voisey's Bay de
posit lies partly within a 30-100 m-thick sheet of troctolite, which i
s interpreted as a flat-lying part of a feeder for an adjacent intrusi
on, and partly at the base of the intrusion, where the feeder adjoins
it. Ore types range from disseminated sulfides in troctolite, which in
crease downward, grading into massive ore. The latter is underlain by
a breccia composed of fragments of gneiss, unmineralised troctolite an
d peridotite in a troctolitic matrix that, in places, contains appreci
able sulfide. When most major Ni-Cu sulfide deposits, including those
at Kambalda, Western Australia, are viewed in the light of studies at
Noril'sk, Sudbury, Jinchuan and Voisey's Bay, three factors become app
arent: (i) the concentration of sulfides in channels or conduits throu
gh which much ma,oma has flowed (feeder conduits for intrusions are mu
ch more prospective targets for exploration than the base of the intru
sions themselves); (ii) the interaction of the source magma with count
ry rocks, either leading to the incorporation of sulfur, or the felsif
ication of the magma in question; and (iii) fractional crystallisation
of sulfide liquid giving rise to Cu-rich ores which may be far remove
d from the 'source' ore.