Mutations in a human homologue of the yeast DNA mismatch repair gene M
SH2 (equivalent to bacterial MutS) cause the condition hereditary non-
polyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC). Cancers in HNPCC originate within
benign neoplastic polyps termed adenomas. Adenomas are clonal and eac
h may serve as a marker of a single initiating mutation. The progressi
on of adenomas is marked by increasing size, dysplasia and villosity.
These characteristics can be taken as the morphological counterparts o
f the stepwise accumulation of mutations implicating oncogenes and tum
our suppressor genes. The aim of this study was to link the morphogene
sis of hereditary colorectal cancer with recent insights into the role
of DNA mismatch repair genes. The frequency and anatomical distributi
on of adenomas in at-risk members of HNPCC families was the same as in
an autopsy population. This suggests that the HNPCC gene does not ini
tiate the process of neoplastic transformation. On the other hand, ade
nomas in at-risk members of HNPCC families were more likely to show vi
llosity (p < 0.001), high grade dysplasia (p = 0.002) and probably inc
reased size (p = 0.15). These findings are consistent with the observa
tion that the HNPCC gene causes DNA replication errors to develop and
accumulate within neoplastic but not normal tissues. The effect of the
HNPCC gene is to accelerate the progression of adenoma to carcinoma,
but not to initiate adenoma development.