Al. Grimes et al., Informed consent and neuroanatomic correlates of intentionality and voluntariness among psychiatric patients, PSYCH SERV, 51(12), 2000, pp. 1561-1567
The authors examine the less-studied components of patients' autonomous dec
ision making, or decisional autonomy, in the light of current research in p
sychiatry and neuropsychology and developments in the construct of informed
consent. The three components of decisional autonomy-understanding, intent
ionality, and noncontrol or voluntariness-are related to clinical construct
s in psychiatry and neuropsychology, in particular to executive control fun
ctions. The authors review studies that examine deficits in prefrontal cere
bral function in schizophrenia, depression, and some anxiety disorders that
are related to intentionality and voluntariness. Assessment of decisional
autonomy should encompass evaluation of impaired intentionality and volunta
riness, not simply impaired understanding. The main response to finding suc
h impairments should be to provide treatment to ameliorate them. New strate
gies for psychiatric care should be developed to address the clinical chall
enges of an increasingly complex view of decisional autonomy.