New maps of knowledge some animadversions (friendly) on: Science (reductionist), social science (hermeneutic), research (unmanageable) and universities (unmanaged)
P. Checkland, New maps of knowledge some animadversions (friendly) on: Science (reductionist), social science (hermeneutic), research (unmanageable) and universities (unmanaged), SYST RES BE, 17, 2000, pp. S59-S75
Valedictories are extremely rare at Lancaster University. Persistent questi
oning eventually extracts an Inaugural from all Professors, but later on th
ey slip away. I felt I wanted to give this lecture and am grateful to the U
niversity for giving me the chance to do it. Allow me a personal introducti
on to start with, though the whole lecture will be a personal retrospect. I
t can probably be said of Valedictories, as has been said - by Theodor Ador
no - of psychoanalysis: 'only the exaggerations are true'.
This lecture is dedicated to the memory of my wife Glenys, who died in 1990
. Loving her for the forty-three years I knew her is the best thing that's
happened to me in my life; losing her, the worst. Since I lost her, wheneve
r I've faced any dilemma I've asked myself what her advice would have been,
and I've always known the answer.
Glen had a great sense of style, as the many people here tonight who knew h
er would affirm. She understood better than most that to live a human life
is to exercise a craft skill. It's a shaping skill, and Glen was very good
at it. If I had asked her whether I should give a Valedictory she would hav
e said: "Well, you gave a naive Inaugural in which you indicated that you w
ould try to bring the human dimension into Systems Engineering. You've been
at it at Lancaster for twenty-nine years. Of course you must give a Valedi
ctory; the aesthetics of the situation require it."