D. Garnier et E. Benefice, Habitual physical activity of Senegalese adolescent girls under different working conditions, as assessed by a questionnaire and movement registration, ANN HUM BIO, 28(1), 2001, pp. 79-97
Objective: The aim of this study was to measure habitual physical activity
in a group of Sereer adolescent females from Senegal. The hypothesis tested
was that physical activity levels of adolescent Senegalese girls differ ac
cording to location and living conditions and may have a negative impact on
growth and nutritional status.
Design: Studies of physical activity within the framework of a longitudinal
study of growth during puberty.
Methods: All the adolescents were born and had been raised in the same rura
l communities, but some worked as maids in the cities during the dry season
(migrants) while the others remained in the villages all year round in ord
er to help their families in daily domestic and agricultural tasks (non-mig
rants). The study was undertaken in both rural and urban settings on a subs
ample of 40 migrant and 40 non-migrant girls aged 13.4-15.3, drawn from a c
ohort of 406 adolescents followed up since 1995. Nutritional status was est
imated from anthropometric measurements; sexual maturation was based on sta
ge of breast development and occurrence of menarche. Intensity and patterns
of physical activity were derived from movement registration by accelerome
try for a 3-day period. The nature and frequency of daily tasks were evalua
ted by questionnaires.
Results: As a whole, the adolescents studied here were smaller, thinner and
less mature than girls of the same age from developed countries. Migrants
weighed 3.5 kg more than nonmigrants and had more muscularity and a thicker
fat subcutaneous layer. The day-to-day reliability of accelerometry counts
was excellent (intraclass correlation coefficient: 0.90, 95% CI: 0.85-0.93
). Mean daily (24 h) physical activity counts were higher for migrants than
for non-migrants. Migrants spent more time engaged in moderate to heavy ac
tivity than did non-migrants (9.3 h/24 h versus 6.1 h/24 h). Non-migrants s
lept or were inactive for a longer period than migrants (7.6 h/24 h versus
6.3 h/24 h). They also rested for a longer period of the day (2.1 h/24 h ve
rsus 0.8 h/24 h). When examining the influence of maturational status on ph
ysical activity, there was a clear difference between the two groups: the l
ess mature migrants were more active, whereas the reverse was true in villa
ges, where girls at the end of puberty reached higher intensity indices.
Conclusions and implications: In both situations, the activity level was hi
gh. The nutritional status of migrants was better despite a heavier work lo
ad. Differences could be explained by better living conditions and food int
ake in cities.