Multi-agent immunosuppressive therapy has produced improved survival for se
vere acquired aplastic anemia in children. Recently, some investigators hav
e suggested that immunosuppressive therapy may replace bone marrow transpla
ntation as first-line therapy for this disorder. To assess its validity, we
compared the outcomes of bone marrow transplantation vs immunosuppressive
therapy in one institution from 1987 to 1997. We studied 46 consecutive pat
ients less than 18 years of age who presented between January 1987 and Apri
l 1997. Inherited marrow failure syndromes and myelodysplastic syndromes we
re excluded. Patients received immunosuppressive therapy vs bone marrow tra
nsplantation based on availability of HLA-matched donors. The main outcome
measures were survival, complete marrow and hematological remission, or par
tial remission but achieving independence from transfusional support. Twent
y patients received multi-agent immunosuppressive therapy (cyclosporine, an
tithymocyte globulin and methylprednisolone); 11 attained complete remissio
n and three partial remission for a transfusion-independent survival of 70%
. Six patients died of infectious and hemorrhagic complications. Twenty-six
patients were transplanted and 24 (93%) achieved complete remission; one a
chieved a PR, 25 remain transfusion independent with a median follow-up of
5.9 years or 70 months. One patient developed AML 34 months after successfu
l transplant and one patient died due to graft failure and complications of
transplant. There has been a striking improvement in survival for pediatri
c patients treated with multi-agent immunosuppression in the last decade. H
owever, transplantation results have also improved and this remains the def
initive first-line therapy for severe acquired aplastic anemia in this age
group.